4G SpeedTest Showdown: G2, EVO, Epic, R2-D2 DROID (3G) [UPDATED]

UPDATE:The highest speeds attained with my G2 so far are 5,951 kbps down and 1,326 kbps up, achieved in separate tests. Also, a T-Mobile rep has confirmed that HSPA and HSPA+ connections are not differentiated by an icon in the notification bar, or in any other way that would be apparent to an end user. Many other people have reported blazing fast speeds with their G2s on HSPA+, so coverage in my area is a considerable factor in the results seen in the video below. END UPDATE

Before we go any further, I’m going to throw out a very unofficial disclaimer on T-Mobile’s behalf (I haven’t been able to get an official answer on this) regarding HSPA+ connectivity and speeds: This video is not at all representative of what HSPA+ is capable of. So, there you have it.

When I shot my my G2 unboxing and hands on video, I was disappointed in the data speeds I saw with the SpeedTest.net app. The speeds I get in my apartment are generally bad on any network compared to what I see in Uptown Charlotte, so I decided to give four phones–HTC’s G2 and EVO, Samsung’s Epic, and Motorola’s DROID 2 (R2-D2, a 3G device)–a shot at SpeedTest near the heart of the city. Ugh. As you’ll see, the results weren’t that impressive, especially for T-Mobile.

All phones were set to test using the same server, which was 193 miles away. Under About > Phone, the G2 showed HSDPA connectivity rather than UMTS, as it is showing while I write this. I had an “H” symbol in the notification bar with full bars, and I’m thinking that I was connected to an HSPA+ network that just needs some kinks worked out and is experiencing its first few days with a hot new product accessing it. I could be wrong.

Regarding the existence of different notification bar icons for HSPA and HSPA+, the manual makes no distinction. Please see a snap from the booklet underneath the video. If you have a shot of an icon unique to HSPA+, please post the link in the comments. This is an area of confusion in the community right now, and I don’t yet have a firm answer.

Whatever the cause for problems, I plan on re-testing–if only the G2–once I see a jump in speeds. (I hope I see a jump in speeds!)



Tags: ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Its your coverage area on the G2. I get over 5k on a Vibrant in Las Vegas.

Samsung Captivate with HSUPA enabled... http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=784147 and that is on AT&T's 3G network. They DO have the fastest 3G network, that is true (I guess as fast as Sprint's 4G?) but can you imagine how fast AT&T's 4G will be?

Oops, I posted the wrong link http://i302.photobucket.com/albums/nn110/ik789usa/HSUPAresults.png but I have gotten faster than that multiple times.

H+ is the symbol for hspa+ , its on the cover of every Accesory for the phone, walk into any tmo store for proof, regular H means its just 3G

I know there is a logo for it, but can you find an image with a phone showing that as an icon that indicates connectivity?

I thought Sprint told us there would be a 1m upload cap, therefore not to be unexpected up times. I live in uptown CLT and I'm getting an avg of 6 down 1 up.

T-Mobile has the worst coverage and most of their customers and reps are just ghetto.

wow, thanks for sounding like an ignorant fool!!!

i hit 7.29down and 0.55up with my g2 orlando fl

and if u look the symbol for the hspa and the hspa+ and 3g on the g2 are all the same so u could have bend on 3g with the g2 and not have known it

wow my samsung vibrant on 3g on 2bars gets 4.27Mbs down and 1.30Mbs up

I've consistently been getting between 6 and 7 mbit down....

I am in Atlanta with a MT3GS. At home I get 5.13 mb down, 1.55 mbs up with a 74ms ping...a few miles down the road though these numbers drop drastically, with 3G and full bars. I really hope that the G2 can do better than this brick of a phone.

John, you are going to do a re-test because you love your new G2 (nothing wrong with that!) be honest! It's good that you should show this video anyway - even though it doesn't go the way you obviously want it too. Bet you wish you hadn't taken that "r2d2 droid" along, made the G2 look bad. Oh well, keep up the good work chap and don't let results get in the way of your opinions!

lol It helps if you use the same download servers.... what an idiot. In the video each phone is hitting a different download server. Set them all to a really fast download server and see how well it works then. Here in KC i always get faster download speeds hitting the chicago server versus any local like the wichita, ks one use on the epic.

Well... John is NOT an idiot, but I do agree with you. The different servers are causing the major differences here, especially on the G2. Manually select the server (Columbia is close to you) on all the devices, then run the tests again!

As stated in the text above and the text in the video, all phones were set to the same server, which was 193 miles away. I did it before the test, and the servers apparently reset or something.

Dude, you have no ideal... huh??? All the tests were done on four different servers. The video does not lie.. Below is the list of servers you used in order. 1. Charlotte, NC 2. Wichita, KS 3. Wilson, NC 4. Columbia, SC

Come on John... Don't tell people they're wrong about the server. Just look at your video. SpeedTest's app shows a different server for each phone. Maybe be a little more observant next time? Might make for a more consistent review.

Addressed in a follow-up video (will post tomorrow), and I'm not sure why my comment edit didn't stick. The servers were all set to match 10 - 15 minutes before the video, but changed when I went away from the app and came back.

Comment for test..test edit

I can't argue with that...sadly

Yea I noticed some of the phones were testing through the same server and some weren't. I know you said you set them to the same one but it didn't appear to be the case.

its all those damn Christians fault.

woah thats odd maybe its a software issue im getting 6mbs DL and 1.5 MB UL

I think the point of this article is more that your coverage bites the big one.