Breakdown: Android 2.3 vs iOS 5 for iPhone

When it comes to rivalries in technology, Apple and Android may be relatively new to the ring, but that doesn’t mean the two don’t make for some of the most interesting headlines in the industry. Well today, the next round of the mobile-tech fight is about to kick off. Apple has announced iOS 5 and all the new features that come with it. How do those features compare to what Android already offers? Are there any big advantages of one OS over another? Let’s take a look.

Notifications

iOS users have been asking for a new notification system for a long time now. In iOS 5, users will be able to see notifications from the lockscreen, as well as from the Notification Center. What is the Notification Center you ask? It’s a pull down window accessible from the status bar at the top of the screen that houses all of your ongoing and incoming notifications. Instead of those little blue pop-ups in iOS 4, iOS 5′s notifications will appear in the status bar.

The Android way: In case you couldn’t tell from the description above, the new notification system in iOS is nearly identical to Android’s. Of course Apple has put their own graphical spin on the system, but overall it’s very familiar.

NewsStand

NewsStand is rather difficult to to form any new comparisons around between iOS and Android, because essentially, it’s an enhanced version of iBooks but for newspapers and magazines.

The Android way: Android has plenty of options for consuming written material, from nook to Google Books, with a plethora of apps between. Look for Google to come out with something that more closely rivals NewsStand sometime in the future.

Twitter

Twitter integration with iOS is something that was recently rumored, that should make for a solid social experience. The big news with Twitter and iOS is that you will sign into Twitter from the main menu, and all apps will use that single sign in for any communications with Twitter related apps. For example, sign in in the main menu, send photos and links through the camera app and browser with that username.

The Android way: You’ve always been able to use Twitter with any app on Android through the commonly found “share” function. The Android way simply let’s you choose which Twitter app to use.

Safari

The new Safari for iOS includes several changes like tabbed browsing, a “reader” function, and a “reading list”. Tabbed browsing is self-explanatory, reader mode formats webpages to be easier to read (think big blocks of text), and the reading list is a bookmarked list of articles that you can save for later reading (it also syncs across devices).

The Android way: Multiple windows in the Android browser have been available from the beginning, but real tabbed browsing has yet to make an appearance. The reader function in iOS is a no show as well. It will be interesting to see how Google handles these features.

Reminders

In the amount of time I’ve spent with iOS, I’ve never seen any shortage in GTD (getting things done) apps, but apparently Apple wants to take it to the system level. Announced today, there will be a new reminders service in iOS 5 that syncs across devices.

The Android way: Our very own John Walton has spent quite a bit of time finding the best of the best when it comes to GTD apps on Android, and there are certainly some great ones out there. Syncing, web-support, different UIs; Android’s got ‘em all.

Camera

According to camera statistics out there, the iPhone camera is among the most popular on the planet. So how will Apple change it up to make it better? First off, they are making picture taking times quicker. You’ll also have access to the camera from the lockscreen; there’s been changes to the focusing and zooming functions; there is now built in picture editing in iOS; and you can use the volume up button to activate the shutter.

The Android way: The camera on the iPhone is difficult to compare to Android as a whole, since there are so many out there. Extremely fast picture taking has just debuted on the Sensation 4G from HTC, and there are several devices being manufactured right now that have a dedicated camera key. If you’re looking for picture editing, give PicSay Pro a shot, you won’t regret it.

Mail

The mail application for iOS is one aspect of OS that has always seemed behind compared to others. Available in iOS 5, users will find a ton of changes that will attempt to make your mail experience smoother: flaging, pre-formatted messages, better search capabilities, draggable addresses, enhanced security for enterprise users, and a built-in system wide dictionary.

The Android way: If you use GMail, there is no better mobile mail experience than on Android. Unless Apple was to simply copy over every aspect of GMail on Android, it just wouldn’t cut it.

PC Free

Yet another long-awaited feature for iOS comes in the form of “PC Free”. From iOS forward, users won’t need to connect to iTunes to use their devices. iOS will utilize wireless connections for everything from iTunes, to OTA updates.

The Android way: Wireless sync has been around for Android for quite some time. Music, pictures, updates; you name it.

Game Center

If you are a big gamer on iOS, you’re sure to appreciate the changes made to Apple’s Game Center which include photos for friends, turn based game support at a system level, recommended friends, and recommended games.

The Android way: Unfortunately, Android has a ways to go before catching up to the gaming department on iOS. Open Feint and the Amazon Appstore have been a big help, but the platform is still rather lacking.

iMessage

Of all the new features and functions coming to iOS 5, iMessage, in my mind, is the biggest. If you took BlackBerry Messenger, and and put an Apple spin on it, you’d get iMessage. It’s a messaging app the works over your data connection, and can communicate with any iDevice, allowing you to send messages and pictures. It also enables real time updates, showing you when a recipient has received a message, read a message, and is typing, along with the ability to sync across devices.

The Android way: Android has a wide selection of data messaging apps, including Google Voice. When BBM is made available on other platforms, it will be exciting to see how the standard in messaging apps fares against iMessage and Google Voice.

So that’s it for the top ten new features that will be added to iOS, and how they compare to Android 2.3, Gingerbread. As you can see, Apple likes to do things themselves, while Android gives you lots of options and lets users handle it in their own way. When it comes to which platform you choose, it really adds up to personal preference.

There is one important thing I should mention, before I go, that definitely puts a new spin on this list: iOS 5 won’t be available until this fall. By then, Ice Cream Sandwich will be out, and the game could be entirely different. The complete feature set for ICS is still a mystery, but we do know one thing: for mobile competition, this fall is going to be great.

Pictures via This is my next

Tags: , , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

Great article about Android and iPhone!  I'm both an Android and iPhone user and I find it a lot easier to use and navigate the Android phone that I have. Without a doubt, these two are the top and largest in the mobile industry. Who will be the third player in the market? That remains to be seen. http://techmaso.com/android-devices-top-the-iphone-5-on-three-categories/

Palm had background images, touch screen, thumbnail images, and icons in rows and columns... Old Palm video. Look familiar? Language seem similar? http://m.youtube.com/#/watch?v=q2gjCALLIuY

task killer?? depends on the phone, i dont use any task killer, the GB takes cares about RAM, not me. Who is blaming Apple, applefan, ? if you are ashamed about your brand new iOS its your problem, not ours,  you really need to use an android, seems you dont know nothing about multi task One thing agree with you, games, nothing more

excelent review, focus and clear, in my opinion, GB is way better than iOS5, Apple presented that things like a great breakdown or something really cool, maybe for iphone´s users, but android users had been using long time ago haha

the thing is if you can get a good phone you have nothing to worry about but i do agree that android is not the most user friendly os . But if you are techy  you can have a lot of fun with android like rooting. 

for your information, even though android produces a ton of apps doesn't mean they are of good quality. Quality outperforms quantity, definitely in the app category and that is where IOS destroys android.  And as for the whole idea about android producing fast products with great features, that is because android is unleashing these devices with killer specs that are only meant to overshadow the iPhone.  It's as if they don't even care about the product, just what is on it. That's why in the near future, these android phones will not have a great resell value.

Apple designs something for quality first and features second. If you don't remember from when they announced the iPhone 4, he said this is not just another phone. This is a phone where we spend 10 months developing the camera. My nephew dislikes his android. He doesn't like the selection of apps and the fact that it's so open sourced he has stability issues. Apple has safeguards to make sure your phone doesn't crash from opening an app lol. I don't care if these features are copying someone else because that's what society is all about taking an idea and making it better. And I can almost guarantee when apple releases these like features. They will perform better. They will be feature rich. And best of all they will be stable. Their phones may have faster Hardware but will it last like my iPhone did for 4 years? If you need some evidence on quality. What's an android chasis made of? PLASTIC. What's an iPhone made of? Redesigned glass that is 20 times harder than plastic and stainless steel. There ya go...

"What's an android chasis made of?" Really? so all the android models in the world are made of cheap plastic. Fanboys like you makes the rest of us look better. You iPhone is also made in China just turn it around and look. "so open sourced he has stability issues" why don't you show an issue that being 'so' open source has? lost for words? I'm sure you haven't even used an Android phone before. It has more features and options giving the user freedom to chose quality, features or both. you don't HAVE to limit yourself to what Mr. Jobs think you should.

i'll bet your android crashes a lot more than my iPhone...

actually probably does but I am using an experimental modded 2.3.5 Rom (CM7)

Great article :-)  And I'd just like to add that any phone running stock Android can set either volume button (or the search button) as the shutter for camera.

I wonder, what was the Name of the phone with the first 3.5 completely touch screen that revolutionized the world of phones. Android !. Err. wait. I mean Apple. You're mad? Oh my... Android, as in the complete OS, would not exist if it wasn't for iPhone OS. It's not hard to one up the OS that came out first.. Doesn't AOS (Android OS) users spend hours customizing your phone from your computer, giving you complete freedom of creativity. You mock iOS for not having that, yet iOS had it first.. Jailbroken iOS > AOS, Rooted or not. So stop saying "Apple is late" no... we were first, and AOS is steady attempt to one up iOS. But understand, OS's need certain feature. Apple takes this or that, I'm not denying that. But, Think of any phone using AOS, THEIR WHOLE BASE IS BUILT ON A BOOTLEG iOS. Never Forget it. 

I thought MacOS (from which iOS was built) was a Frankenstein ( made up of bits and pieces of other software such as FreeBSD and NetBSD), based on The Mach Kernel developed by Carnegie Mellon University, NOT! apple, and UNIX also NOT! apple. Now when it comes to iOS, well this is a MacOS child so the above mention also applies to iOS. Based on this I can say that apple was not first to anything, let us review the following FACTS! Was apple first to: touch screen cell phone market, Portable music players, touch pads, PC's, the answer to this questions is NO! indeed apple was late to many things and every time apple adds a "new feature" it has already been released by someone else.  Android is NOT based on iOS, instead is based on Linux, originally developed by Mr. Linus Torvalds. But to be fair Android is a very young OS and still improving, also keep this in mind, iOS debuted on the iphone a year before Android and now iOS/Android market share is about the same if not surpassed by Android in some markets. And just so you know I own a hackintosh for 3 reasons 1. Because I can build a hackintosh, 2. I like MacOS  X better than windows and 3. I am not willing to pay twice as much for an apple branded product so I am not an apple hater, but rather I hate fanboys that post based on their imagination and not FACTS!

so true, android was created from the iPhone.  If apple never produced the first iPhone, Google would have never thought it necessary to produce android.  And if you think about it, it's funny how the iPhone 4 was the first phone to include a front facing camera, now every android phone has a front facing camera.  Even though many say android is ahead of iOS, why is it that last year's iPhone 4 is still out pricing many newly released android phones on the market? Apparently, it has something android is lacking.

Nice comparison. I appreciate that you close with,  "As you can see, Apple likes to do things themselves, while Android gives you lots of options and lets users handle it in their own way. When it comes to which platform you choose, it really adds up to personal preference." That pretty much sums up the differences. It doesn't mean one is inherently better than the other. It all about preferences. I won't jump into the current flame war about Apple copying other features, primarily because it's nothing new. All of the producers of various OSes have been above explicitly or implicitly copying features from one another. We shouldn't be surprised that it's happening here. A couple of quick notes.  1) There's a typo in the first sentence of the NewsStand section. 2) I'm a little surprised that you completely skipped GoogleTalk iMessage section. GoogleTalk is something that is baked into the Android OS, and it's available on different platforms (Apple forces you to use iChat instead of allowing a stand-alone GoogleTalk app). While I don't believe there's a way to see when messages were received and read, all chats are archived in your Gmail or GoogleApps account. Video chat through GoogleTalk on Android has come about recently, too. It's already available on personal computers.

Actually, from what I understand, the true tabbed browsing being introduced in iOS 5 will be iPad only and will not make an appearance on the iPhone and iPod Touch.  In that case, the browser in Honeycomb for Android tablets, has had true tabbed browsing from day one.  Once again, Apple is late to the game.

The dolphins browser has tanned browsing

Honeycomb has tabbed browsing

I love how Apple is always suing everyone else for copying them.... yet iOS5 is flat-out copying Android and Blackberry. Seriously, if you ever want to see what's coming to Apple next just look at what was new to Android two years ago. With the whole Apple VS Samsung issue going on right now in mind I actually laughed out loud when I first saw the pull-down notification system. I laughed again when I saw the iBBM.... err- I mean, "iMessage".

This is the first head-to-head comparison where iOS was playing catch-up in almost every area, and by the time iOS 5 is released they'll be playing catch-up again!

its kinda weird how ur comparing stock apps to 3rd party apps for android. especially since most them have a app store counter part.

isnt this article supposed to be comparing the os's? not what you can find in a 3rd party app?

A nice breakdown - and good job on keeping it balanced! Many of the posts I've seen today argue that iOS 5 copies elements of Android, and to some degree it certainly does. However, the fact is that they both (still) have their strengths. Looking at it objectively, iOS 5 will be a *great* upgrade come this fall! I'm excited to have it on my iOS device. Of course, as you said at the end of your post, I'm excited to see what future versions of Android will bring as well!

FINALLY iOS doesn't feel like an OS from 2007.

Regarding tabbed-browsing: Dolphin Browser HD 5 does a perfect, amazing job with tabbed browsing. And it also has a reader feature built in.

Gotta love options.

You have options in iOS as well look for iCab mobile, opera mini, atomic browser, ...

Don't the Opera browsers have tabs too?