Editorial: How Long Does An Android ROM Last?

This has been a question in the back of my mind ever since I flashed my first ROM on the Samsung Captivate almost two years ago. It seems so long ago, but the question remains: how long does a ROM last? It has really come to mind while on a cross country road trip, watching my current ROM deteriorate over time.

This has been a problem across all phones I have used, be it Samsung, HTC, or Motorola. This also does not apply only to rooted phones, but seemingly to all Android phones. Now, this is purely anecdotal, and your mileage may vary, but it seems to be much less of a problem on unrooted phones. But the longer you keep the same ROM, the slower it gets.

In this case, my ROM lasted approximately 4 weeks. This is awfully short, and I’ve never had a ROM last this short of a time. It started out blazing fast, truly showing off the wonderful hardware in the Exynos-based Galaxy SII. Currently, it takes half a second between presses in Settings and the keyboard often lags. Again, a ROM has never deteriorated this fast for me before on any phone, but this strange occurrence has caused me to really think about this issue.

My girlfriends stock Motorola DROID 3 has deteriorated quite badly over time. My mothers rooted Captivate deteriorates after a few months and requires a reflash. My Galaxy SII needs a fresh start every few months too (my flashing addiction has calmed down lately). Often, wiping cache helps, but not fully. You’ll need a good factory reset to get everything working as fast as it should. Even the latest Ice Cream Sandwich bogs down, and no slower than Eclair ever did. This is strange of a consumer product. You don’t see an iPhone bogging down nearly as much (yes, it does, but not at the same rate), nor do Windows PC’s nor Macs slow to a crawl in less than a year. Google, you should change that sometime soon. You’re lucky many people don’t mind and those who do mostly know how to fix it. With Titanium Backup and root, it takes 10 minutes max, so it’s really not a big deal to me. But this shouldn’t happen in the first place.

But really, I’m curious about your experiences with this issue. Name your phone and how long a ROM lasts until it’s slower than an HTC G1 (I’m going to get so much hate for calling the G1 slow). We want to know, how long does your ROM last? And is there any way to keep away the inevitable? Tell us in the comments!

Tags: , , , , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Se3ek 8 pts

I'm on CM7.2.0.1 on my original HTC Desire now but I've never had those issues in my whole time I had the device. There's only one problem for me. I have to tell you, I turn on my data-connection only when I need it, so I turn it on and off about 3 times a day in average. After a few weeks it just doesn't turn on anymore, then I have to wipe the cache and it works again. But speed-wise there was never any sloe-down for me. The longest period I was on a Rom was "only" half a year though.

A friend of mine had this issue, though, when he was running CM (I don't know which version) on his Motorola Milestone 1. He had to reflash every week to keep the performance up which eventually made him buy an iPhone 4s.

I'm on the Droid X currently running Liquid remix 3.2.1. The longest ROM i've used is Liberty. I regularly flash between Gummy, MIUI and variations of CM7. It's amazing their is still strong development for my "ancient" Droid X.

I'm running a SkyRocket on CM9 nightlies now, don't think I can vote with that since every other day I reflash a newer nightly(but I don't factory reset it). Previously running SkyICS 4.1 or 4.2?My parents and brother are running slightly different versions of either Cognition or Perception from DesignGears. Going on for about a year now on all three devices since I last flashed/factoried/cleared cache/anything. Basically I set it just over a year ago and never touched CWM on them again.

I keep offering to update them to CM9/CM7 or at least the last Cog release, they're content with no complaints of lag.

joshavon 5 pts

I agree with this article 100%.  I've owned both the Motorola Charm and the LG G2x (T-Mobile version and rooted with Cyanogenmod 7).  Both android phones - whether it be from the manufacturer or rooted - have deteriorated over time.  I'm not sure why this is.  It's very frustrating.  One of my friends has the GSII on Sprint and he has said the same thing.  Android really needs to fix this obvious flaw with the OS.

bspitzer 6 pts

I've been using ICS Passion on my Vibrant for almost 4 months now. Not one reflash and I'm still a happy camper! No real lag from fresh install and less than 10 phone resets (the ones where the phone just can't figure it out and restarts on it's own). Phone is restarted every 4-7 days by me. The old Froyo ROM, while buttery smooth would need a reflash every 2-3 months. My old G1, (which BTW Dima was AWESOME!) had Cyanogen making so many roms, they were never more than a few weeks old until it was time to upgrade so you never noticed the lag. Alas, until a few months after I got the Vibrant and pulled it back out, then it became obvious. Good times flashing roms, don't you all agree!!!!

roboguy12 31 pts

I've been running AOKP on my original Droid Incredible for over a month now, and I don't really have any problems like you're saying. Granted, it never moved as fast as a newer phone would have simply because the hardware isn't present to do so, but I never experience such severe lags that I would consider reflashing the ROM. Maybe I'm just lucky?

astontopgears 19 pts

Thankfully, I have never had this problem. Now that I'm running CM9, it's perfect. I've been running the same ROM for 4 months and I haven't noticed even the slightest bit of sluggishness. 

bydavidrosen 8 pts

THANK YOU for this article. I've been an Android enthuiast ever since the G1 and have personally converted over a dozen friends to Android and honestly... I have no idea why. Every Android phone I've had (G1, G2, MyTouch 4g Slide, HTC One X, and then back to my MyTouch 4g Slide for now) has been pretty much awful. Stock has always been slow and laggy and choppy (not counting the one x of course) and with roms has always been great for a week or two until things go bad and I'm spending another Sunday afternoon wasting hours reading the forums and flashing new roms, just so it will run better for a week or two.

 

Don't get me wrong, I still love Android and hope my next phone will be Android too (maybe the next nexus?), but it's ridiculous how these rom's deteriorate over time. I would gladly flash a less advanced, more simple rom if it would last me, issue-free, for the next 6 months. But I doubt that will happen.

 

Currently using Virtuous Inquisition by the way on my Mytouch4g Slide. Great ROM, except of course the fact that it's been 2 weeks since flashing the last update and i'm having all kinds of issues now. It ruled for the first 2 weeks though :-)

Liskrig 8 pts

I was using the 6/18 build of CM9 for my GNex but I had to upgrade due to a boo-boo I made... BUT it was running fine. I think the longest I went with a single ROM was with my Droid Incredible, I was using a RC for about 3-4 months and it never seemed to slow down. MIUI on the other hand... will last me about 4 days, then it lags horribly. 

bydavidrosen 8 pts

 Liskrig the inconsistency in roms is the most frustrating thing. the longest rom i've ever been on was a MIUI rom on my old g2 (before it died) that lasted like 4 or 5 months or something (up until the phone physically died on me).

brooksdbrewer 5 pts

Hmm... Currently on my HTC Inspire I'm running MikRunny Sense 3.5. I haven't noticed it slowing down yet, and I've used it for about...3 months? When I used RCMix, I ran the ROM for 8 months in a row, and it never really slowed down.