Editorial: The Root and ROM Flashing World Isn’t Worth It Anymore

Just about 2 years ago, in 2010 (seems like such a long time ago, no?), I purchased my first Android device. After playing with my friends DROID, I needed to have one of my own, and purchased a Samsung Captivate. At the time, it was the super phone to have. It featured the original Super AMOLED display, a 1GHz processor, a 5MP camera, and I could not have been more happy.

Prior to that, I was an iOS guy. I owned the iPhone 3GS before the Captivate, and the difference was night and day. The Captivate was capable of so much more, with integration to Google services like nothing I’d ever seen. But that wasn’t enough. I wanted more.

About a month or so after I got my Captivate, I took interest in the world of rooting phones and flashing ROMs. My 3GS was jailbroken for the majority of the time I owned it, and I figured it would be more or less the same on Android. That was my first mistake. After about an hour of getting my Captivate rooted, I started to look into flashing my first ROM. The moment finally came, I flashed the ROM, but there was one mistake: I forgot to back everything up. Long story short, I screwed up the first time, with nothing but a sour taste left in my mouth.

Over time I got the hang of things, and about 15 Android devices later I hit a point. I no longer had any desire to root a phone. There was a time where I was buying, selling and trading Android phones like there was no tomorrow. Most of the time I would get them pre-rooted, from outlets like XDA. With each new device came a new set of ROMs, and I almost felt obliged to try them all. Android itself was not enough for me. It was either too slow, there were features offered through a different ROM, or a new mod only worked with a certain ROM. And there was not a single ROM that did not have one flaw or another.

I could not be pleased.

Anyone who is familiar with flashing ROMs will know that it is simple enough, but comes at a cost. There’s always backups to be made, apps to be installed, and accounts to be synced. As time went on, I got more and more busy, making flashing a ROM more of a chore than anything. I no longer had time for it, and made the realization: is Android really worth it if I have to modify it, just to make myself happy?

And I finally made the decision: if I need to root it to make it usable, then it is not worth it to me.

That decision has worked out very, very well for me over the past few months. Starting with the Galaxy Nexus, Android was finally ready for me. Sure, there were a few instances where the device would get bogged down, and my urges to flash a new ROM would return. I fought them off. Manufacturers seemed to fix even that slightest bit of lag, as shown by the Samsung Galaxy S III, the HTC  One X, and even the Pantech  Marauder. Custom UIs fixed the lag, and did not add to it.

Jelly Bean made Android smooth, and I haven’t had an urge in the slightest to root my Nexus 7. I’ll touch back on this again towards the end of the year, but for now, Google and its manufacturers are doing something right.

image via IntoMobile

Tags: , , , , , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
Deke218 12 pts

I recently was blessed with the HTC Amaze as a insurance replacement for the T-Mobile G2x.  The G2x NEEDED a custom rom.  Force closed as least 5 times a day on the stock rom.  It was garbage from the day I got it.  I custom ICS rom took care of all its ills.  The Amaze is simply amazing.  Had it for a month and not one FC of any app in all that time.  However, I did root it but only to get rid of the bloat.  No custom roms on this puppy! 

ErickIldsGarcia 5 pts

Last Android device i rooted was my Evo4G over a year and a half ago and i found myself rooting and un-rooting it over and over again after seeing that most roms weren't as stable as the stock build so after i got rid of that i got a Galaxy S2 and never looked back. After that I got a Galaxy Nexus and now own a Galaxy S3 and a Nexus 7 and I couldn't be more pleased. The only instances that i can see anyone rooting any phone for anymore is if you want to tether for free or if your hardware is outdated and aren't getting anymore updates.

nayshonka 5 pts

if you use nice stable roms then it is worth it. i have had my Samsung captivate for about 2 years now and i have aokp loaded on there. i get better battery life, android 4.0, and all the customization that comes with aokp. if i would've had to stay with the stock rom/ stock launcher it would've gotten stale after a while.

astontopgears 19 pts

This article is incredibly unsavory for the Android community. Flashing ROMS and modding is what makes Android GREAT.

Spoken Word 33 pts

 astontopgears I agree. Every other article on here lately is deriding Android in some way. I'm beginning to think the site has been infiltrated by iTerrorists.

Kreekhoorn 5 pts

@573W1E flash back to ginger Bread,now root and flash a rom with brick bug disabled. Btw it is usually said if there are s note features or not :)

TreeNguyen 9 pts

If you look for stable roms they are stable. When I flash new rom its because I want some new feature and something new to look at but the main reason i flash new rom are the battery life, tweaks, slickiness and smoothness! I always love flashing hehe

bydavidrosen 8 pts

just commented on the facebook post and figured i'd copy it over here too... 3 rooted android phones and so far the ROMs barely do a thing to help. i completely agree with this editorial... here's what I said on facebook for anyone that cares:

 

Couldn't agree more with this Editorial. It always ends up being more trouble than its worth. I spend hours and hours reading the forums wasting my time so I can flash a ROM so everything will work amazingly for a week or two before it goes back to the same old issues. Someone will likely respond and say "then you're not doing it right" or "you're loading it up with crap" but I have a total of 68 apps loaded (including the preinstalled ones) which I think is absolutely nothing compared to what I'd like to have installed on my $600 phone (I'm constantly deleting games and stuff that I'd really rather not remove) and have tons of issues on my current phone. Only reason I haven't wiped it yet because it's too much of a pain in the ass to set everything back up and I know that the issues will just start up again after a couple weeks anyway, so I'm waiting it out until my next phone which I will not root.

Brooks Barnard 30 pts moderator

 bydavidrosen Rooting doesn't have to mean rom flashing.  It may be a gateway drug, but users can have a complete stock experience with a rooted device.  I partially agree with Joey, I feel like the need to root has been lessened.  The android experience has evolved and doesn't need the help it used to.  However, I still love the fact that I can do a nandroid backup.  The other day, I sideloaded an app that froze my device.  I restarted my phone and I couldn't get out of the lock screen, it would just freeze.  What would a normal person do? Maybe not sideload an app in the first place, but still, that sort of thing could happen at any time.  I backed up my phone the day before and just restored it.  No harm done.  Not a big deal.  What would I have had to do if I wasn't rooted?  Maybe a factory reset?  That would suck.  And I agree with JQuest81 , it's just fun to do.  It's fun to try out other roms or jelly bean previews, even if it's only worth it for an hour.

bydavidrosen 8 pts

 Brooks Barnard  while a nandroid backup is great for what it is (a backup), i always worry i'm just gonna have the same issues if i restore my backup and continue on from there since i'm dealing with a not 100% stable rom to begin with haha. other than backing up i can't think of a reason i'd want to root other than if the phone itself sucked in the first place (which is unfortunate, like is the case with my mytouch4g slide).

Brooks Barnard 30 pts moderator

 bydavidrosen I guess I wouldn't do a backup unless it was set-up I wanted to come back to...  something I know is stable and I'm mostly happy with

JQuest81 87 pts

Generally, I root for fun, not necessarily to fix a problem or try out a new ROM  per se (Though it's always awesome to see what the dev community cooks up). I like to try out the latest and greatest from Android... so I keep an extra device around for development purposes..

 

The main reason I root any device (particularly my daily driver) is to REMOVE CARRIER BLOATWARE and some of the various tweaks they make (i.e. like the constant wi-fi notification on the VZW GSIII anyone?) Also the fine folks over at XDA usually have a tweak, feature or app or two that enhances the experience on your phone without need for a new ROM... with the most shining example that comes to mind right now is Google Wallet.

ryanmahan97 5 pts

I think that my samsung captivate would have gotten old and boring by now if I hadn't flashed any roms. It keeps the dying phone, after your 19th month of a 20 month contract, still alive and kicking and changing, I got to a point where I was flashing three or four roms every week and it was fun for me, kept my phone alive and up to standards, IMO, after a year.

Brooks Barnard 30 pts moderator

Just because Joey wrote this doesn't mean it reflects the feelings of everyone working at DroidDog ;)

573W1E 18 pts

Having a phone like the Galaxy Note is annoying for me because after 8 months of owning it I'm no longer entirely happy with it. The main issue I have with it is that is just isn't fast. While it will put up with everything I throw at it like games and video in day to day usage it lags. Badly. Now I have thought about flashing a custom ROM (I am already rooted) But then this leaves me with 2 problems, while they may not matter to others, they certainly do to me. 

1) The Galaxy Note suffers from that eMMC bug that even a factory reset could kick off which pretty much scares me away from doing any sort of serious tinkering with it.

2) Some ROMs don't have proper support for the S Pen and any of its apps, and I do tend to use the S Pen alot.

 

Just my thoughts. I guess to others what I mentioned wouldn't be a problem at all.

Was this story really necessary?

nathan118 15 pts

Was this comment really necessary?

TheDark_Knight 77 pts

@Anon No...but is ANY story necessary? Nope...

nathan118 15 pts

 TheDark_Knight  Anon So you're literally arguing for NO stories. Like there should never be a story of anything, because none of it is necessary. Ok smart one.

TheDark_Knight 77 pts

@nathan118 Look up the definition of necessary and desired, then get back to me. "...smart one."

nathan118 15 pts

 TheDark_Knight  nathan118 Haha, nice try...go back to being annoying and void of usefulness.

TheDark_Knight 77 pts

@nathan118 Apparently looking up definitions is too for you to do. Thanks for the irrelevant reply though. It makes you look very..."smart".

I understand the Story. Android is Open source. In that, it is so appealing. I have an Amaze as my dd. It however does not have a stable AOSP rom yet. So when i feel like using aosp. I go back to my T-mobile G2 phone. It is a thing of beauty. If i had learned about rooting. custom recoveries and roms/kernels. I never would have bought my amaze. It might not always be necessary to root but it sure is fun.

aliasgx 5 pts

if your rooting to make YOUR phone better.  Then sorry you got the wrong phone for yourself.  With android you have so many choices.  It's not like getting an iphone it's just the wrong choice from the get.

Matlock 12 pts

@aliasgx honestly, if I'm buying a carrier variant of a phone, I will definitely root it. I hate all the carrier bloatware that gets put on phones, that you can't uninstall, without having the phone rooted. That's basically the only reason I root my phone now. Also, having root access helps me fix my phone on my own, without having to contact the manufacturer or the carrier to fix my phone.

jpb 14 pts

I would agreewith you except for two reasons.

 

1.   Verizon

2.   Google Wallet

j_dav1 5 pts

@jpb I agree. Although when I rooted for those things I went ahead and put a good rom on the s3 to get some stuff from jelly Bean.