[Editorial] Has Android Finally Reached The Stage Of Bigger Is Always Better?

If you hearken back to a simpler time, say about, oh, two years ago, you’ll remember when Android phones really started to gain their momentum and skyrocket to the top. You had phones like the DROID X, any of the original Galaxy S series, and the HTC EVO 4G. Over the short period of time from then to now, a myriad of things have changed in our pocket-sized computers but one of the most dramatic changes that has happened has been with that thing that you incessantly stare at on the phone, the screen.

When the DROID X and EVO 4G launched, they became quite popular due to their powerful specs but more importantly, their screen size. At the time that both phones were on the market, most phones didn’t have screens bigger than 4″. Yet the DROID X and EVO came along and changed the way that people looked at their phones in regards to the screen. Suddenly, people coveted the larger screen preferring to have that extra real estate to view things on rather than have maximum portability.

But if you preferred a phone with the same kinds of specs but a smaller screen, then you could find several options readily available. Of course, there was the iPhone which had a 3.5″ screen but if you preferred Android then you had lots of options. For instance, a high-end phone with only a 3.7″ screen was the DROID Incredible, a highly popular option. If you wanted a little more screen but still wanted portability and great specs then one of Samsung’s Galaxy S offerings fit the bill nicely.

Then things began to change as time continued to pass and phones continued to be released. Screens gradually began to conform to the new standard of 4″-4.3″ and specs went with them. Then the Galaxy S II, Epic 4G Touch, EpTouch for short, came out with a 4.5″ screen and great specs to accompany it and that quickly became a new size for screens. That’s when the trend of bigger is better really took hold with manufacturers. Options started to become tighter for people who wanted a phone with a smaller screen and decent specs. Those looking for a high-end phone with a small screen were having trouble finding what they wanted as the high-end specs were being paired with large vibrant screens and small screens were left to buddy up with the lower-end internals.

And progress continued to happen, phones began to release with even larger screens like 4.65″ on the Galaxy Nexus. Those once familiar small screens and good specs became a rarity and small screens were reserved for budget Android phones that often launched on prepaid carriers. Instead, the dying breed was rapidly being replaced by a new class of superphones that weren’t defined by only their guts, but by their external veneer.

But if you thought that things couldn’t get any worse for those lovers of the small screen then think again. Enter the Galaxy Note. Signifying the next evolution of the smartphone, the enormous phablet had a screen that measured at a ridiculous 5.3″. People passed it off at the beginning as a niche phone but after sales quickly picked up, people began to wonder if this is really what’s coming next. Now sales of the original have crossed ten million and the newest member of the Note family, the Galaxy Note II, has entered the picture with an impossibly bigger 5.5″ screen.

And the great divide has fully taken place with all of the mainstream manufacturers releasing their latest flagship phone with 4.7″ or greater screen sizes. They’re selling like cheap electronics at Best Buy on Black Friday but for the people who want a high-end Android phone without the massive screen, luck has run out. The three that come to mind that kind of fit in this category are the HTC DROID Incredible 4G LTE, Motorola DROID RAZR M, and HTC One S. Even saying that isn’t exactly truthful as all of them have sister phones that have better specs and of course, a bigger screen.

This theory has been driven home lately with some of Sony’s offerings that bring a smaller screen but lack the powerful internals of their families. But the icing on the cake came today with Samsung’s new option of the Samsung Galaxy S III Mini. The afore-leaked phone was anticipated to be a Galaxy S III put into a smaller body with only a 4″ screen instead of the sizable 4.8″ screen on the actual Galaxy S III. Instead what we got was a phone with a shrunken design reminiscent of the S III. Everything else was different such as 4″ 800×480 screen, 1GHz dual-core processor, five megapixel camera, and other low-end/mid-range specs. Contrary to offering an actual miniature Galaxy S III, Samsung let people down and released another low-end phone with a small screen while further cementing the idea that a bigger Android phone is always better.

While I love large phones, I can’t help but think that Android manufacturers are ignoring a fair portion of the market that’s seeking a high-end phone with a smaller screen. When their options run out on Android, they’re left to look at other platforms and looking them straight in the eye with a tempting proposition is Apple. The largest iPhone, the iPhone 5, is just 4″ but packs a hefty punch in the specs department and therefore can allure people looking for a small, portable smartphone that can hold its own against the big dogs.

But my long-windedness is starting to get the best of me so it’s best to cut it off now and pose the question to you, ladies and gents’. Do you believe that Android has reached the stage of bigger is always better? Or do you think that there’s still hope for smaller high-end phones running Android? Perhaps you have a different view. Use that keyboard in front of you and feel free to share your thoughts, opinions, and insights in the comments as I’m ready to hear some other ideas on the matter.

Tags: ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest

I completely agree with this. If you have a car and drive to work and sit at a desk all day (which, admittedly many people do), then larger phones present a better experience with limited compromise. However, for those of us who live in cities and walk around and like to pop out to dinner without carrying a bag all the time, there is a huge need for small, pocketable phones.

JoshLazenby 7 pts

I can't entirely agree with this. While there are sparse options when it comes to smaller screens, its not impossible to get. The article talks about how all the good phones with smaller screens have much lower specs. The One S, though, is one of the most powerful phones on the market with one of the best cameras. While it doesn't have a 3-4 inch screen, its still not a behemoth 4.5+ since either. That said, some more high end options in the 4-4.3in area might be a good idea. I just wanted to throw it out that there is at least one high end device with a smaller screen. :)

kanoneyez 71 pts

Perhaps an interesting study (and survey) would be to ask two main questions:

 

1. What do you do with your smartphone? Talk only, talk-n-text, surf web, play games, watch video.

 

 2. What size screen do you prefer: small: 3-4", medium 4 - 4.5", large 4.5 = 6"? 

 

I don't know, but I would venture that those who watch videos and play games prefer larger screens, while those that merely use voice (but why have a smartphone if that's true??) or text prefer smaller phones. Those who occasionally surf the web are probably satisfied with medium screens while those that spend a lot of time on the web probably prefer larger ones.

 

There is, as others have noted, a good mix of the all those consumer markets. Perhaps the manufactures feel that "feature phones" are more toward the needs of those preferring smaller screens, so they don't bother with putting power into smaller smartphones. Again, I don't know, just a hunch

 

achusaysblessyou 7 pts

I think the majority of the market is moving towards larger screens, while some people want smaller screens, I don't think the market is large enough for manufacturers to create high end phones with high price tags when most consumers will think the phone with the larger screen is better and so why would they pay the same price for something smaller. You know what they say, bigger is better :). (I am biased as my next phone will be the Galaxy Note II, but I think a 4.5" phone is a happy medium)

jhernandez4688 13 pts

I happen to love my Galaxy S3, I am a 6'tall guy with big hands. The phone feels absolutely amazing on my hands. My last phone was a MyTouch 4G Slide, my kids have those, and the difference in the screen is amazing. I can understand that some prefer a smaller screen, so you have choices like the new Galaxy S3 Mini. The phone is not as powerful as the original, sure. But I see it as a smaller kid brother. I am can understand why they gave it lower specs. The bigger, the more powerful. The smaller, well, you get the point. I know some friends that want smaller screens, the problem here is that companies cater to the majority, as long as more people want bigger and better, this is what they will produce.

MdXMaxX 21 pts

Android is about choice, but the manufacturers are doing a really crappy job of giving consumers options. This article speaks the truth. I mean really, the only high end phone with a qwerty keyboard nowadays is the DROID 4, and that's aging.

MarcOKelly 10 pts

I really want the note 2 but I have to save money for college

TheDark_Knight 77 pts

It's all good. Samsung's got your back.