Come Tomorrow, Unlocking Your Phone Will Be Illegal Unless Done Through Your Carrier

Some carriers might be facing a serious problem soon. Starting tomorrow, January 26th, it shall be illegal to unlock your phone by any means other than through the carrier that sold it to you. This means that carrier unlocking (which is easy on most Samsung devices using root) will be illegal, the DMCA (Digital Millennium Copyright Act) made sure of it.

This could be a lot of trouble for pay as you go carriers, as well as T-Mobile. Carriers like that encourage you to bring your own phone, and you won’t be able to unless it’s from Europe or your own carrier agrees to unlock it. It would be a lot harder for those companies to get customers with their own phones, meaning they lose out (since some don’t offer high end phones and people avoid them), as do the customers having to settle with expensive carriers or low end devices.

What about your rights? You bought the phone, shouldn’t you own it? Well you bought it for a fraction of the price, and are paying the rest off through your contract. In a sense, until your contract is over, you’re still paying it off. However, you can do an engine swap on a car you’re still paying off. Why not unlock a device?

It’s a complicated issue that does not bode well for consumers. What do you guys think? Is it understandable or outrageous? Tell us in the comments.

TmoNews

Tags: , , , , , , ,

Post comment as twitter logo facebook logo
Sort: Newest | Oldest
crazygal 5 pts

Got a good response from the white house about legalizing cell phone unlocking. here is the source: https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/make-unlocking-cell-phones-legal/1g9KhZG7 The recent ruling that effectively bans third-party unlocking has ruffled more than a few feathers, and the people have spoken with their electronic signatures---14,322 of them , to be exact. Now the petition to the White House, which asks that DMCA protection of phone unlockers be reconsidered, has finally received an official response, and it appears that it's for the positive. You can still get your phone unlocked from any third party vendors like http://www.mobileunlocksolutions.com/  ..there is no issues ..

PolyTien 5 pts

If this illegal issue bothers you, and you want to have the option to be able to unlock a device you believe you paid  for and own, then sign this official Petition and pass it along: https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/make-unlocking-cell-phones-legal/1g9KhZG7 . There's still time! 10 days left to get 100,000 minimum signatures.. At present, there is 66,000 sigs.. Please pass this  petition link around to help make a difference! And, btw you don't have to reside in the USA to sign, and if u need to  create an account u don't have to put any identifying info in it 

ChristopherDaniel 7 pts

The new policy only applies to new locked phones purchased after Saturday, meaning it will still be legal to unlock phones purchased before January 26 without permission.  ~CNN

JœyMømbïnī 5 pts

So I have tmobile and if I buy a AT&T phone FULL Price I wont be able to unlock it since I don't have AT&T???

Haloruler64 84 pts

 JœyMømbïnī Essentially. You need AT&T's permission to unlock it. 

LeahGoodspeed 7 pts

That is bull.. I bought my phone from my carrier but because i was not due for an upgrade i paid FULL PRICE so i should be able to do whatever i want with MY PHONE..

ChristopherDaniel 7 pts

 LeahGoodspeed Agreed.... And you may want to contact the carrier with that argument... What the new "Policy" says is that it's carrier discretion... So if they see you bought it outright, they may unlock it...Hard to say, but it's worth a shot... 

NicholasSpeed 6 pts

Retail customers arent affected by this. Only if you purchase with a discount does this apply. @LeahGoodspeed

TheDark_Knight 77 pts

WTF! What about buying phones off of eBay and Craigslist? Anybody know?

ChristopherDaniel 7 pts

 TheDark_Knight It's only for UNLOCKING THE DEVICE to work with another carrier... Has NOTHING to do with unlocking the bootloader to root, or buying a device through EBay/Craigslist/etc....  It's supposedly to circumvent buying a phone through AT&T at a cheap price, and unlocking it to work on T-Mobile, For Example...

Haloruler64 84 pts

 TheDark_Knight If you buy it off eBay and it isn't unlocked, it's illegal to unlock it yourself or use a service that requires IMEI as far as I know

NicholasSpeed 6 pts

Retail customers arent affected by this. Only if you purchase with a discount does this apply. @TheDark_Knight

ChristopherDaniel 7 pts

Wrong.... According to Droid-Life, Rooting and Unlocking your bootloader is Legal (for now)... HOWEVER, unlocking the hardware (SIM Card) to make it either a global phone that you can take overseas, or flip to a different carrier (AT&T unlocking to work on T-Mobile) will be without carrier permission....  The Librarian of Congress is the one that "determined" this.... 

Haloruler64 84 pts

 ChristopherDaniel We never said rooting or unlocking bootloaders was illegal. It remains legal. However, some phones require root to unlock, like Samsung devices can be carrier unlocked using a root procedure. I guess I should clarify that.

ChristopherDaniel 7 pts

 Haloruler64 I gotcha... Once I went back and reread that, it was a little bit more clear... There's also a petition floating around you might want to include as well... I will post the link once I track it down again....  Bad thing about that petition is, it's on the White House Website, so it'll require 100,000 signatures in order to be considered... The whole thing is a joke if you ask me.... Thank you DCMA...

Haloruler64 84 pts

 ChristopherDaniel Yeah, my bad for stating it a bit strangely. Thanks for bringing that up. And the newest article includes the petition. 

iFrenzy 6 pts

The whole argument about subsidized pricing is old.  If buy the phone subsidized and then immediately cancel, you are still going to pay the ETF, so you are still paying for the phone.   I have no idea what unlocking a cell phone has to do with copyright.  You bought the damn phone, you should be able to use it where you want.

Haloruler64 84 pts

 iFrenzy If the ETF is paid, the phone should be legally unlockable. However, if you're in a contract and have not paid off the phone, that's the gray area. This new law goes beyond the gray area and screws over people who paid full price for devices. 

NicholasSpeed 6 pts

Retail customers arent affected by this. Only if you purchase with a discount does this apply. @iFrenzy

Tuliomesa82 23 pts

so that includes unlocking through imei? or jailbreaking?

Haloruler64 84 pts

 Tuliomesa82 Yep. Any source that isn't your carrier, including services that use IMEI

NicholasSpeed 6 pts

Retail customers arent affected by this. Only if you purchase with a discount does this apply. @Tuliomesa82